A respected colleague of mine recently posted something on Facebook saying he read an article about a superintendent in Florida who made a policy in their school district that no homework shall be given to any students 6th grade or below.
She saw research from other countries that have adopted this and felt that students that got a break from school work when they went home performed much better. They avoided burnout and mental fatigue.
Students are encouraged though to read 20 minutes a night. And I think that is fair.
Upon seeing this article though, comments from the peanut gallery say something along the lines of “I had tons of homework when I was a kid and I turned out just fine.”
Now, I admit, I’m at the age where I can look at a couple generations younger than me and would possibly be one of those people to say such a comment. Upon thinking about it, not just this topic, but similar topics, I’m now willing to explore the other side of the argument a little closer.
What do I mean?
For instance, there are a lot of topics in sports where you will see similar comments. Currently in the NBA, you have the older generation and fans complaining about the NBA stars that are taking time off during the season.
I can see where people would say, Michael Jordan didn’t take games off. Or this star and that star didn’t take time off. Actually Jordan did take time off. Right smack in the middle of his career he took a season and a half off and then another season or two before making his second comeback.
Maybe those two breaks were what his body needed to play at the level he did for as long as he did.
I think we have selective memory when it comes to our NBA stars. Yes, a lot played close to the full capacity of games during a season. But, how long did they play? Only a few made it past 15 years and how productive were those players who did make it past 15 years.
I don’t know what the research shows, but maybe by taking time off in the season these NBA players can play more productively than their predecessors did when they get up to the latter part of their career.
Only time will tell, but when you look at the other side, maybe an NBA star would say, “Yeah I played all the games I could in a season without taking games off, but would I have had a more productive last few playing years if I HAD taken some games off during the season.”
We are learning new things day in and day out. At one time athletes smoked and drank beer in the locker rooms before and after games. Then we learned that might not help athletic performance and so we stopped.
Before, we jump on someone making a claim that is contrary to the norm, maybe we take a second to pause and think about if that claim could hold some legs.
I do think there are plenty of current trends out there that I totally disagree with. I’ve been as open-minded as I could, but you aren’t going to sell me on them. I.E. everybody needs a trophy.
But, I will be a little more thoughtful about these trends before I make my final decision about them. Sometimes, I will say “back in my day it didn’t hurt US to do that.” But, maybe in other instances I will think that the trend has some legs and maybe being a little more open to the idea would be the smarter play.
What do you think? Feel free to leave your comments in the box below.
Photo courtesy of Bea Serdon on Flickr: https://www.flickr.com/photos/beaserdon/
Leave A Comment